Big Bucks,
Deer Season 2000 PAGE 2
PAGE 1
PAGE 2
PAGE 3
PAGE 4
Ralph Reynolds of Linn, MO
Randy Simonitch - Bowling Green, MO
Randy Kasten - Jaskson, MO.
Trey Lawfield -New Madrid, MO.
Tim Taylor - Pilot Grove, MO
Geoff Lester  - Freeport Ill.
Dustin McAffrey -Neosho, MO.
Nick Panagos - Jackson, MO.
Steven Sanders - Audrain Co. MO
Mike Beatty -  Xenia, Ohio
Andrew French - Bertrand,MO.
Jeffrey Smith
 Gregg Wilmoth - Mt.Vernon,MO.
Bruce Scherer -Benton,MO.
Michael Harvey
Mark Courtway, Bloomsdale, Missouri
MISSOURI
SPORTSMEN

TRADITIONAL
ARCHERY
EQUIPMENT

HUNTING
FISHING
BOATING
CAMPING
SHOOTING
ATV'S
LODGING
HORSES
OUTDOORNEWS

HUNTINGLAND
FORSALE

SPORTSMENJOKES
ORGANIZATIONS
LAND OWNERS
COFFEESHOP
LINKS
LOCALWEATHER
TAXIDERMISTS
SPORTINGGOODS

MISSOURI
BIGBUCKS
CLUB

Archery Big
Bucks
of Missouri 

Boone
andCrockett

 Missouri 
DeerClassic

buckfax.com

KnoxCounty
Y2K


New Missouri State Record Archery Deer Taken Near Bowling Green 
Confirmed!  The Randy Simontich buck will be at the Missouri Deer Classic!
 
 
 

Randy Simontich with new Missouri 
state record non-typical 
scoring 269 7/8
 Stories are also circulating around the Conservation Cafe' on the MDC's website about a possible new Missouri state record for bow. It is reportedtohave34scoreablepoints, the rack has been scored by a B&C scorer and it green scored 268i nches.  It was taken  in the Bowling Green area. The landowner had been seeing this deer for about two weeks and it was acting very strange. The landowner actually has a video of the deer the day it was taken, copies of the video may be for sale at a store called Joe's Jug somewhere around the Bowling Green area. 

As the story goes the landowner got within three bean rows of the deer while shooting video, the deer was watching her the whole while, then just got up, walked about 75 yards and laid back down in the bean field. She called her neighbor who came over and shot the buck at about thirty yards after getting it to stand up with a grunt call.

 This story suggests there was something wrong with this buck, aside from being tired of carrying around his massive non typical rack. There have been no reports of any studies, blood tests or otherwise to confirm or deny any illness. 
Quote from Bowling Green news paper "We watched that buck through out thesummer in my and my neighbor's field". On Tuesday, I hunted early in the morning.By late morning, a neighbor called to let him know the deer was spotted in a field. I went back out and caught sight of his horns in a bean field..... I took my shot, I saw the deer leaping away with the arrow stuck firmly in its side. He shot the deer at approximately 11 am, and found it around 3pm...The temperature was 85 degrees, so the deer was beginning to stink badly.. 
..He and a neighbor loaded the deer into a truck, and he promptly put it on ice and covered it....." 

Latest News! 
This big buck killed in Pike County, Mo. on 10/3/00 by Randy Simonitch, was officially scored last week (12/4/00) and the final tally is 269 7/8.  That has shattered the previous Missouri record bow kill of 220 7/8 and the previous record gun kill of 257. 

Any further information or photos would be greatly appreciated.  If you have any let us know. TMVIDEO@KVMO.NET 
For more details about this once in a lifetime buck scroll down to the next two stories.
 

back to top of page

Stories and photos about this Simonitch buck reprinted from the Bowling Green, MO. area news papers.

Buck Fever

Bowhunter Takes 34-point Deer, Possibly State's Largest
The folks at Bass pro, Cabelas and other major outdoors companies may soon get to know Randy Simonitch very well. 

The Bowling Green man has bagged a monster buck worthy of the trophy rooms at the two outdoor goods retailers.

Initial measurements give the rack 34 measurable points on seven brow tines (four on one side, three on the other).  The spread between the twomainbranchesspans20 inches.  The racks beam measures 28 inches. 

One estimate put the bucks age at six years and Simonitch guesses itweighedabout250pounds while alive. 

He says he is keeping the deer's jaw in case an official age is needed to be determined later.

The unofficial green score compiled by scorer Jay Hurd puts the racks total Boone and Crockett Score at 268.  However, Hurd stresses the green score is an early measure.  An official score can not be given until the antler shave dried for 60 days.

The current state record in Boon and Crockett scoring, which accepts deer killed by gun or bow, is 259.  Hurd is confident Simonitch's rack will be the largest ever taken by a bowhunter in Missouri. 

The current bowhunting world record Pope and Young score, which uses the same scoring as Boone and Crockett, is 279.

The rack must dry for 60 days before an official scoring to be done. 

If the rack's score meets the early estimates, Simonitch may be in for some traveling.

Such a score would likely put his buck at the top nationwide.  Such a place earns an invitation to the Boone and Crockett national banquet, where a panel of four scorers score the nation's biggest racks.

Simonitch says he has been called by a couple of nationwide outdoor magazines, but has not heard yet from big hunting retail companies.

Taxidermist James Graham says such a buck may also attract large hunting companies to seek Pike county land to lease for hunting.

Simonitch harvested the possible record setter in a soybean field behind a friend's home. 

People had watched the deer in the field from their house on several occasions, according to Simonitch.  He says he saw where the big buck had beds down some thirty times in the field after he had shot.

The big hunt began after a fruitless morning of bowhunting on his own land. Simonitch headed to the field after getting a call from his friend to let him know the buck had been spotted.

He moved to the field and slowly made his way to the buck, working a little bit closer every time he could see the bucks head.

He took the shot about 35 yards away from the deer.  Simonitch says all kinds of things went through his mind when he finally found the deer two hours later.  I was surprised when I found it.  I was surprised at how big is was.  It is like a dream come true, he said.

Hurd says Pike County residents will probably never see a deer like this one again. 

"It is a once in a lifetime type of rack"

Now that's Some Buck Fever!
Local Deer Kill May Set World Record
By April M. Bonds
Randy Simonitch, of rural Bowling Green, Killed the buck that has the residents of Pike Countyand the surrounding area talking about a possible world record. 

"We watched that buck throughout the summer in my and my neighbor fields." Simonitch said of the possible history making deer.  Simonitch shot the deer with a bow and arrow on Tuesday, Oct 3, near his home outside Bowling Green. The buck has approximately 34 points and field dressed at around250 pounds. Simonitch " neighbor had gotten very close tothe deer and shota video.  The video was setup at Joe's Jug in Lousiana after the kill.

On Tuesday, Simonitch hunted early in the morning.  By late morning, a neighbor called to let him know the deer was spotted in a field.  Simonitch went back out to hunt and caught sight of the horns in a bean field. 

The crop was over waist high, so all I could see was his horns over the top, Simonitch said. " The deer's head kept disappearing in the crop.  I used my grunt call to get his attention, then took my shot" Simonitch explained.

He saw the deer leaping away with the arrow stuck firmly in its side. He shot the deer at approximately 11Am and found it around 3 p.m.. The temperature that day was around 85 degrees, so the deer was beginning to stink badly.
 
 
 

 


Simonitch and a neighbor loaded the deer into a truck and he promptly put it on ice and covered it.  He was trying to preserve the hide so he could have it mounted. 

The deer was checked in at Elliott's in Bowling green.  It was tagged, without any notice of its enormous size. Simonitch put the deer in his garage until Jamie Graham of Wild Creations in Frankfort could look it over.  When Graham saw the tremendous rack with its impressive span, Simonitch said Graham just kept saying, "Oh my God" and backed away from it.  Graham added, "I've seen some really big whitetails, but that's the biggest I've ever seen."

Graham was quick to return the deer's rack to Simonitch.  "I didn't want to keep it in my shop,  I didn't want to be responsible for it Graham remarked.

Once the deer is officially scored after the standard 60 days of drying. Simonitch will bring the rack back for mounting.  However, Graham has advised Simonitch not put the original antlers on the mount Graham commented that it's common for hunters to put the original antlers in a  vault and mount replicas.

Pope and Young is the official record book for archery kills.  However,  Boone and Crockett will likely score this deer and enter it into their record book.
 
 
 

 

This deer should definitely break the Missouri state record in both Pope and Young and Boone and Crockett.  In Pope and Young the Missouri state record is 220 inches.  Boone and Crockett's Missouri State record is 257 inches. 

The pope and Young world record is over 279 inches, The Boone and CrockettworldRecordIs333inches.  That deer was found dead in the St. Louis area.

Graham expects this deer to score between 270 and 280 inches,  So it will probably not break the World record deer found in St. Louis that's in the Boone and Crockett record book.  It could break the Pope and Young world record. Simonitch will have to patiently wait the 60 day drying period before the deer is officially scored.

Until then, Simonitch has the deer in a safe place. He is enjoying the fanfare that comes with thrill of the Kill.  Rumors are as vast and unlikely as one might imagine.

I've allegedly been offered $100,000 for the deer's antlers, Simonitch said.  He hasn't seen the money though.

Simonitch also heard that the taxidermist (Graham) couldn't mount the deer's head because it was too big.  That is also false. 

No Mater the rumors, this kill will be a great story that Simonitch can enjoy telling for years to come. Simonitch remarked,  "I just wanted a big buck to hang on my wall, that was as big as my buddies."  He got his wish and much more.

back to top of page

NewPope and Young World Record Possible, No Probable!

Geoff Lester, Freeport Ill.
Taken outside of Stillman Valley on October 27. The deer is quoted to be a 10 pt. typical that field dressed at 195lbs., G2s and G3s near 16" long. main beams of almost 30", and the base is approx. 7" around. . They say P&Y scoring puts it at 218 inches gross before the 60 day drying period. The columnist says that after the drying period it will still probably score near 208 inches. The current world record Typical is 204 4/8". 
 

Photo and story from (Rock River Times Nov.15-21)

back to top of page

Bagged Deer In Line For Record


 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Sunday, November 19, 2000 

Dave Golowenski
For The Columbus Dispatch

With the whitetail season only eight days hence, let us pause with wonder at an Ohio deer story and a possible fable. The first assuredly is legitimate, the other yet to be confirmed. 

Truth is that Mike Beatty, 31, of Xenia, Ohio, used a compound bow inGreeneCountyonNov.8 to fell a buck for the ages. The 250-pound deer wore a39-point,nontypicalrackthat green-scored 291 3/8 by a veteran Boone and Crockett scorer, said Todd Haines, supervisor of wildlife managementf or the Ohio Division of Wildlife district office in Xenia.

"That would be tops in Ohio,'' Haines said. "It's a monster of a deer, and it's going to be way, way up there.'' 

The latter exclamation referred to national rankings by Boone and Crockett, which keeps score of the largest North American game animals no matter what the method of kill.


(AP Photo/The Ohio Department of Natural Resources Division of Wildlife)
Facts About the buck:
 It has 40 points 
 Green Score is 291 3/8 
 Harvested on11-08-2000 
 Harvested in Greene County, Ohio 
 Compound Bow 

So the story goes that Mike had seen a nice buck enter into a thicket, Mike grunted and the buck that came out of the thicket was this trophy, he thought he was getting a shot at the original buck he had seen earlier.  If the score becomes official after the required60 day drying period it will become the new State and World record non-typical buck ever harvested with a bow.
From: http://www.american-hunter.com/monsterbucks/MikeBeattyBuck.htm
 

Some technical questions exist over whether the deer will qualify as a record by Pope and Young, which tracks bow-killed animals. Should it do so, the Ohio buck would emerge as a North American record, surpassing a Nebraska whitetail downed by Del Austin in 1962. That non typical scored 279?.

Beatty's buck won't be measured officially until 60 days pass.

The large-as-life antlers have been moved out of state for security reasons, Haines said, because record racks are valuable to collectors and for display at outdoor shows.

One longtime bowhunter and scorer said Beatty's buck could fetch $250,000.

While Beatty waits, he has hired legal counsel to deal with corporate sponsors and others who surely will come his way wanting to share the credit.Whatever happens, he apparently nabbed more than one buck on his most lucky day.

Meanwhile, a female hunter in Licking County, who is remaining on the sly, used a compound bow to cut down a 12-pointer that weighed 301 pounds, according to one of her hunting partners.

"It's the biggest deer I've seen in five decades of hunting,'' said the partner by phone last Sunday. "It was as big as some cow elks.''

No official word has surfaced, so the 300-pound whitetail remains apocryphal.

Allen Morris - Latest New from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources
News Release
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

January 8, 2001

OFFICIAL SCORERS SAY OHIO DEER A WORLD RECORD -
LARGEST EVER TAKEN BY A HUNTER

COLUMBUS, OH -- A white-tailed deer killed last fall in Greene County is an Ohio record, and if approved by national scoring organizations, would also be the largest deer ever taken by a hunter in the world, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Division of Wildlife.

Deer hunters all over the country have been anxiously waiting for the official scoring of a huge white-tailed buck shot by Xenia bow hunter Mike Beatty on November 8 in Greene County. Yesterday, a panel of judges put together by the Buckeye Big Buck Club met to decide whether the deer would become the top non-typical whitetail ever taken in Ohio, and possibly the biggest ever taken anywhere by a hunter.

A deer's antlers are classified as being non-typical when they are unsymmetrical and irregular in shape.

Mike Beatty's adventure began on November 8 when he shot the huge non-typical whitetail with 39 measurable points. Beatty contacted Ron Perrine, Sr. of Xenia, an official scorer for several antler scoring organizations, including the Boone and Crockett Club, the Pope and Young Club and the Buckeye Big Buck Club. Perrine initially scored the buck at 291 3/8. Antlers are required to "dry" for 60days before an official score can be taken.

The Buckeye Big Buck Club keeps records of large bucks taken by hunters in Ohio. Butch Todd, scoring supervisor for the Buckeye Big Buck Club, organized a panel of four judges, including Perrine, to measure the buck and come up with an official score. At the end of the session, Beatty's buck came away with a score of 304 6/8, making it easily the largest non-typical buck ever taken in Ohio.

"I scored it very conservatively the first time around; it's far better to surprise a hunter with a larger score than to cause disappointment when the official measuring is done," said Perrine.

The score sheet produced by Perrine will be submitted to the Boone and Crockett Club for future inclusion. Currently, only two non-typical bucks score higher than Beatty's buck. Number one is called the "Missouri Monarch" and scores 333 7/8. It was found dead near St. Louis in 1981. Number two is Ohio's "Hole-In-The-Horn" at 328 2/8, found dead by a railroad track near Ravenna in 1940. Beatty's buck should end up listed as number three, but will be the largest taken by a hunter.

"This is incredibly exciting," said Mike Budzik, chief of ODNR's Division of Wildlife. "Of the top three non-typical bucks in the country, two come from Ohio. I couldn't be more proud of our deer management efforts."

back to top of page

Bruce Scherer

Avid deer hunter for the past 23 years has finally taken a buck of a lifetime. Bruce Scherer of Benton, Missouri has harvested a 21 point buck in Bollinger County, Missouri.
    After already taking a doe with his bow this year Bruce, had already decide when Missouri's rifle season came around he would not shoot the first deer he had a chance at. Since he already had meat in the freezer.  But, Bruce did not know this brute of Bollinger County was going to show up.
    The story actually begins in the summer. In the adjacent county of Madison, a buck with a large rack and a drop tine on the right side was seen feeding in some near by fields several times. A few people believe it to be this buck, and near the end of the story I will tell you why.
     The cold morning of November 11th, the opening day of rifle season, was going to be highlight of this 43 - year old from Benton. Bruce, went out on his friends land about 6:00 a.m. walking towards an area he has hunted for several years and, has always had deer come within50yards of the tree.

Scherer Buck 1
Bruce Scherer poses with his 21 Point Buck
After climbing the tree with his Lone Wolf climbing stand, Bruce started working with his seat that would not stay up. With his gun and bag tied to a rope on the ground. Bruce was trying to get the cord around the tree to tie the seat up. When at 6:30 a.m. he heard movement from below.
    A basket rack 6-pointer was working his way by the tree. He decided to freeze so he would not spook this buck and let the buck work it's way to his friends stand over the ridge. But, as luck would have it the 6- pointer came within10ft of the tree and stopped and started looking in the direction of the gun and bag on the ground. It immediately took off running back the way it came but then circled around in that direction anyway.
    Well with the seat fixed Bruce pulled up his gear and sat the gun on the seat and hung his binoculars on one side of the seat and bag on the other. But, what Bruce had forgotten, was to put the cord around the tree in a different direction. When Bruce picked up his gun the seat folded up and all his gear fell 20 feet to the ground below.
    Well with daylight already on him and with very little confidence he would see anything large enough to shoot. Bruce decided to leave the stuff lay.
    About 8:30 a.m. across the wooded valley on the other ridge in front of him. He watched a deer flag it's tail and run over the ridge. Then, watched two or three more deer walking along the ridge also. Unsure if any of the deer where bucks, all Bruce could doi s wait.
    Wondering, why the deer had flagged. Bruce then heard walking in the valley in front of him. Bruce could not see what it was because of the thick brush in that area. Then, finally Bruce saw some movement around60 yards. He watched this buck turn it's head and large rack to one side, then to the other side, working slowly through the thick brush.
    Bruce raised his Remington 7400  30.06andput the scope on what he could see but all that was visible were antlers. The buck then turned out of the brush headed straight at the tree he was in. This is when he knew how large a rack this deer actually had. He kept the scope on the deer but the angle was very bad. All he could do is see the rack getting closer and no chest shot was available and the antlers kept him from taking a spine shot.
    Finally, the 21  pointer had closed the distance to 5 feet from the base of the tree directly below Bruce and near all his gear on the ground. The buck turns its head to one side and this is when Bruce puts the crosshairs on the shoulder and pulls the trigger. The shot hits the deer on top of the shoulder and runs 50 yards back in the direction it came from. This time the 22  pointer stops broadside and Bruce was not taking any chances. He fired a second shot just behind the shoulder and the buck took off running but tried to cross a ditch and folded.
After taking deer almost every year, Bruce has waited in the stand. But, not on this day he came down the tree and walked over to check out a buck of a lifetime. They had the deer weighed later at around190lbs.
    While talking with Bruce the best thing about this story was the excitement in his voice. You could tell that this was a great moment, great southern buck and great hunter.
 

    The Official Boone & Crockett score from Don Roper of Farmington, Mo. is 218 non-typical, with a 23 3/8 inside spreadandonly2 7/8 difference between each side of the rack. This buck even had the chance of scoring higher but on the right side a broken drop tine was missing. Just like the buck they watched this summer.
    Congratulation to Bruce Scherer for taking this great southern big buck.

Scherer Buck 2
Bruce Scherer poses with his
official 218 non-typical .

back to top of page


THE MISSOURI SPORTSMEN'S INFORMATION NETWORK
MOSPORTSMEN.COM


Site-specific editorial/photos Copyright 2001 Tomorrow's Video Productions.  All rights reserved.
This website is an unofficial and independently operated source of news and information not affiliated with any school, team, league, state, county or country.

back to top of page